Biological Father Problems

Biological Father Problems

My wife and I have been married for about a year and her ex is a huge pain to deal with. My step kids –a boy and a girl- are both less than seven. This guy pays almost nothing for child support and makes every visit miserable for my wife (and me).  He seems to be a major control freak. Everything has to be done the way he wants it- when he drop them off, when he picks them up and sometimes even how long he decides he’ll keep them. He picked them up today and, as usual was a complete jerk about it. He doesn’t give us any notice some times on the days he comes to get them. It’s his day but a little heads-up would be a nice courtesy. My wife is always stressed out before he gets here and she’s stressed out the entire time the kids are gone. Then we almost always get into it with him when he brings them back because he’s so rude in the way he acts. I dread the weekends he has the kids because I know it’s going to be drama. Last week I made an excuse so I wouldn’t have to be home when he came for the kids. I want to do that every week because I don’t want to deal with this A-hole. I don’t know if I can continue to stay in this situation. DO you have any advice on how to deal with a guy like this?  –ArtJSN66

Many Stepdads report that the worst part about the job is the ex-factor. If you’re dealing with your wife’s challenging ex, then you’re in good company –and you’re not alone. I’m sure many of the dads in the Forum will have some nuanced advice so I recommend you pose specific questions on this topic there.  For the moment, let me talk about the situation you’re dealing with.

First: Let’s look at the legal aspects of your situation.8-17-13

Child support-

You mentioned that the father pays “almost nothing” in child support. If this is what the court ordered then you’ve got to be glad he pays it. You might be surprised to know how many men don’t pay anything. Deltabravo.net states that 62% of biological fathers in the US don’t pay child support. It’s reported in divorcemag.com that 74% of Canadian dads with a child support order are generally in a state of arrears (meaning they are not up to date in their payments).  The article on deltabravo.net goes on to claim that most mothers don’t even seek child support, so the statistic is flawed. In fairness of full-disclosure, the article was sponsored by S.P.A.R.C., which is an advocacy group for dads. They report this information as factual but they don’t support the statistic (about mom’s who don’t want child support) with a source. I feel comfortable sharing it because I’ve known plenty of single moms who haven’t asked for support. So there’s surely a good deal of truth to it.

There’s sometimes compelling reasons not to ask for money.  Here are some I’ve seen

1) It would be a waste of time because the father has no money

2) It would create an ongoing battle so it’s not worth the effort

3) It may make him angry. She fears retribution

4) She is self-sufficient and doesn’t need help from him

In a case where you feel a father isn’t paying enough and he isn’t giving enough heads-up when getting the kids and is keeping the kids longer that he’s allotted, then you can have your wife take it to the local District Attorney.  This is the title in most US states. It is probably a different title in Canada. The D.A. can bring it to a judge to reassess the amount he is paying. While this may increase the amount you are getting for the kids and stop the bio-dad’s bad habits with the kid’s visits, it will not help to improve his overall disposition towards you and your wife. If money isn’t really that tight, I’d suggest focusing instead on getting along. A strong working relationship with the bio-dad will strongly benefit the kids’ level of happiness. Building a bridge will also help reduce the stress in your home. What you gain will be much more valuable than the few hundred dollars of child support.


The hard truth of being a Stepdad is that you don’t just marry the wife, 8-17-13 Quoteyou marry the entire situation. Few men fully understand what they are getting into when they marry a single mom. While no two situations are the same… you’ll be hard pressed to find a Stepdad who says it’s “easy.” There are emotional and psychological dynamics that were in play before you even entered the situation. The kids may be torn by their parent’s split up and feel like they have to choose. Your wife and her ex certainly didn’t separate because they got along too well. It’s would be surprising if they were excellent communicators now. Emotions are high and now the father sees another man stepping into his role in the home. There is a very primal thing at work here and it is territorial in nature. Bio dads can feel like the kids belong to them and that the presence of another man in their lives can be frustrating at best.

In most cases biological fathers don’t handle themselves as well as they might. Take a moment to consider how you might feel in his place. If your kids were being raised by your wife and another man who is now the person they interact with in a dad role most often you might feel emotional about it. Men, as you know aren’t known for handling their emotions well. There are plenty of cases of dads who are pushed to the brink when dealing with emotional matters. In 2011 a man shot eight people in a Seal Beach, CA salon, including his estranged wife. The man was in a bitter custody battle with the mother. Luckily, most men handle themselves better than that but it’s important to remember that he is probably struggling with a lot of emotion right now. His rude demeanor and controlling behavior are probably a sign that he’s trying to have some control over a situation where he feels powerless.

If you can muster the internal strength and swallow a bit of pride, asking him to coffeegrab a beer or coffee with you might be a good first step. Let him know that you know he must be dealing with a lot and that you don’t know how well you’d be able to handle it in his situation. Reassure him that you don’t want to replace him. I had this talk with my kid’s bio dad years ago and it has paid amazing dividends in the rapport I have with him. Unless he’s a completely irrational person, he’ll appreciate that you showed him some compassion. Once you’ve settled that you will be in a position to talk about what’s most important; the kid’s happiness. They will certainly be much happier if the adults in their lives aren’t arguing over them all the time, right? You don’t have to love the guy. You don’t even have to like him –but you do have to get along with him until the kids are grown. In fact, as long as you and your wife are married, he’ll probably be around because the kid’s will keep him linked to your family. It’s best to find some common ground –and soon.



  1. Flip42
    September 21, 2012

    A new stepdad..kinda, I have been married for just over a year but dating the same lady 3 yrs prior. She (at the time was divorced and had a beautiful 3 y/o girl) The lil one had very little sporadic contact with her dad the first yr I was in the picture. Now she’s about to turn 8 and the bio father is back. With no contact in the last 3yrs. We are devastated at the thought of this man now coming back into this girl’s life and ours. Drunkard, jail, rehab that sort of thing is his most recent lifestyle, but claims to be over that. For the girls sake I hope it’s true. I have mixed feelings about his return. As a father I hope he becomes a good one. But as a stepdad who is called and considered to be a “Dad”, I feel I will lose some of the relationship with her. I found your situation to possibly be a foreshadowing of things to come around here. The stress my wife feels now just waiting for things to happen (the court is involved) is thick as can be. Our other/my daughter 16 can now easily see the strain in the family over this situation. Good luck to you ArtJSN66. I hope your relationship with the bio guy gets to a manageable point. I would like to hear/read more from your situation if you care to share in the future. -Flip42

  2. The_Step_Dad
    September 22, 2012

    Flip42, Thanks for sharing. There are so many Stepdads who face the same issue. It really can be a challenge. The great bond you've formed with your little girl makes it hard, but it's also the thing that will help you the most if the bio-dad becomes a permanent feature in her life. They may have DNA between them but you have LOVE.

    Keep up the good work, Dad!

    S. James Wheeler, Founder of Stepdadding.com

  3. Biological father
    March 17, 2013

    I am on the other hand,a biological father who pay child support every month, but I have to deal with the mother of my child and her husband. This guy is a joke; he calls me when I have to call my son and he tells my son to tell me “I don’t want to talk with you” my son is only three. Besides that he confuses my son mind telling him that he is his dad…. I just want him to respect my relationship with my son. But seems to me that he hate me so much….. I have to be patient until my son can understand by himself what is going on here..I feel really bad for that guy since my son has something that he never can change ( my son genes ). I want some advice to stop this. Thank you.

    • The_Step_Dad
      March 18, 2013

      Stepdad's listen-up. This is valuable perspective from a biological father. No one should try to block a man from access to his child unless that man is a danger to his kid,

      Biological Father,
      Thanks for taking a moment to share. Reach out to the mother and Stepdad. Talk with him especially and try to bridge the gap. Grab a coffee, a beer, or invite him to a ball game –whatever it takes. If something doesn't change soon your child will deal with un-needed drama. It's common for young kids to develop anxiety, confusion and even guilt because of the pressure they feel from the parents fighting for control. I always advocate for the best interest of the kids. It is the ONLY winning formula. If all the parent figures can agree to make their decisions (and communicate) based on the kid's best interest (instead of emotion or jealousy) the kid's win in the end. When parents engage in emotional tug-of-war with a child, the kid always suffers.

      Guys, always reach out to the other guy in your kid's life. Work as a team. Stepdad's don't fight for the title "dad," Just be the best parent you can be to the kids in your lives. They will appreciate it, appreciated you and grow from your good example.

  4. Frustrated Step Dad
    March 19, 2013

    I'm a soon to be official stepdad, but I've been living with my kids for 3 years now. In our case the ex was abusive to my fiancee and has in three years through the courts been able to achieve visitation bi weekly with double overnights and two full weeks in the summer plus some short weekly visits and extended time for vacations. He has been negligent in many circumstances although nothing has been seen by the court as serious enough to reduce visitation time. The man makes no sense and as soon as we question him about things that go on with the children he immediately responds with complaints to us about things we are doing "wrong." He never owns up to anything and is constantly using the kids as a go between and telling them way too much about the custody battle that is going on. He frequently uses sarcasm and name calling tactics with my fiance. He is making our life miserable and I would also like to know how we can deal with this guy.
    I can't stand interacting with this guy and he doesn't want me to any way because he already knows I have a pretty low opinion of him. However, I feel like I have to be there because it's unfair for my fiance to deal with it on her own. I am worried about her having him hanging over her head all of the time. and she is terrified that something will happen at house and their won't be anyone responsible to make a good decision. Not to mention the concern we both have over what his presence and attitude are teaching the children.

    Sounds like there are a lot of us out there who love being a parent to our step kids but have to grapple with these horrible men to get there. I know there are many divorced bio dad's who are good parents, but these terrible role models who have biological kids are taking away too much time and attention from people who need a chance to help the kids they love grow up healthily.

    • The_Step_Dad
      April 7, 2013

      Frustrated, Thanks for reaching out. This is a complicated issue so we've posted a long form reply to your question. You can find it posted in our Ask The Stepdad section.

  5. The "real" Dad
    August 16, 2013

    I’m the bio-dad. I have joint custody, no child support, and a parenting schedule of one week on/one week off.

    Every time the kids’ mother and I are in the process of co-parenting the negotiations fall apart as she abruptly defers decisions regarding our children to her new husband. This is the same guy she introduced to our children as their new dad while we were still married. The same guy who beat my children with his belt eventually sending my youngest home with bruises and lacerations on his legs from his hips to his ankles. The incident gave me enough ammo to incur an investigation by police and children’s services. The same guy who sends me vitriolic texts stating he’s making up for my lack as a father.

    Needless to say I’m the difficult bio-dad in their minds. But, so long as I have just as much custody and spend equal time with my kids, step dad needs to butt out when it comes to decisions regarding my children. He doesn’t have children of his own, so he’s clueless about being a “father”. As far as I’m concerned it’s the step dads who make things difficult by attempting to be something they’re not: the “real” dad.

  6. Dawa Namgyal
    February 4, 2019

    I am married to a divorce women having a son. I am a step dad raising the son along with my wife. But her ex husband is a huge pain to deal with. He pays nothing to his son though the court has made a decision with a written letter that he is liable to pay in order to raise the son. I have no issues whether he pays or whether you don’t pay but the main problem here is that he tends to distract the mind of the son by saying dad is always there for you, nobody can scold you, nobody can bit you and more so on.
    More over he calls my wife as if like a boss and tells her to bring son to his reach and calls her to come and get the son when ever he wish to. Same time my wife does as per his order….
    To this solution I asked many of my friends for suggestions. They suggest me to tell my wife not to let son deal with useless biological dad.
    Therefore I would like to get more quality answers that can help me out plz! Looking forward
    And same time can I consider my wife too a the one pushing this situation more worst?? Should I charge her???

    • S.J.Wheeler
      March 29, 2019

      Dawa, You’re in a difficult situation. In the US Stepdads have virtually no legal rights. The only way you can have any hand in how things are done is if you wife works as a partner to you. Her actions are making this more challenging than it has to be. By going along with her ex she works against your ability to be a parent. Until she grows a spine it’s not likely to get easier.

  7. jason pitman
    February 27, 2019

    long story short, my wife was not married however had a kid with her ex boyfriend, he has been a grifter for yesrs, uses women of intelligence and monetary of value till he gets caught, he has 6 of not more kids we know of with at least 5 different women, has never raised any of his kids, he assaulted my wife i did the wrong thing and beat his ass, he pressed felony charges for it and it was all dissmissed because he lied, we moved far away and he followed us to antagonize us, due to him being a bio father and me being a stepdad i get shit on, ive raised my son since he was 8 months old he’s now 7, stepson is in alot of trouble at school after his time with his donor, 1st grade btw, i have never had a fathers day, school functions or any time with my son due to her ex causing public issues, the donor tried to start public fights every time and pokes at me avery chance he can, police, schools, and every avenue treats me like nothing due to being a stepdad, what can i possibly do to protect my son

    • S.J.Wheeler
      March 29, 2019

      Jason, I truly feel for you. You’re doing your best and (like all Stepdads) the deck is stacked against you. Most guys don’t understand how skewed the laws are until they become a stepdad. You gave him even more power when you hit him – and he obviously knows it. Sadly, Stepdads are treated like strangers in the eyes of the law, while biological fathers are given special status. DNA shouldn’t be more important than love and caring, but the laws are outdated. The rules are slowly changing. Until then all you can do is be strategic. Be the best parent you can be. Be the kind of man you want your boy to grow up to be. Raise your son to be a smart man and when it matters most he’ll know you’re the one who’s there for him.

  8. Confused new step dad
    March 13, 2019

    I’m a 20 years old and I’m trying to become a step father to my girlfriends child. I was there for the birth and I have been there for the last 14 weeks of the pregnancy and the biological father hasn’t been around at all. And now hes trying to come around but everytime my girlfriend invites him around he acts like he wants to come around but he eventually cancels. When he finally does come around does anyone have any advice for me? Should I be protective or should I just kinda stand back and watch? Should I be jealous or should I relax?

  9. Abraham Joesph Rangel
    May 13, 2019

    I’m the bio dad dealing with a step dad that has already over step his boundaries he took my daughter to a father dance at her school , that I had no idea was going on wasbt told anything plus his now helping coach her games I’m kinda frustrated dont know what to do trying to be humble but getting to a point when I’m ready to snap I pay child support I’m in my daughters live but I’m not being respected as a father from him or my ex …..what can I do to resolve this matter ?

    • Joel W. Hawbaker
      December 1, 2019

      Abraham, that’s a pretty tough spot to be in, and I’m sure it’s very frustrating. To begin with, I would (as much as you can) respectfully ask him and your ex when they’d have time to talk about this type of situation. I know it’s not fair for you to go through what you are dealing with, and if it’s at all possible to become allies with your kids’ stepdad, that will be the best long-term solution. If needed, consider bringing in a third-party mediator (my ex and I have done that on multiple occasions; we find it helps keep things on track and also keeps them from getting less personal and angry). Continue doing the right things, being a good father, paying child support (even if that feels unfair), and loving your kids. But also work toward figuring out common ground with your ex and her husband so that you can all work together for the good of the kids.

  10. Aaron Edwards
    October 28, 2019

    I need help….or at least understanding…..**the situation**….. I am with a girl who has 2 daughters one 4 and the other 2…..the bio dad cheated while she was pregnant with the second one and left and re married in less than a year……he never asked for time with the girls….he signed the minimal once a month visitation…and only saw them when the mother needed a baby sitter….anytime they go over they come back in some sort of meased up they scream and throw fits….they are hungry and haven’t slept…sunburnt or cut up like they haven’t been watched at all….the girls are 4 and 2 and he didnt even have carseats for them…now that I am in the picture as a step dad role….he all of a sudden wants more time with them…..and the only thing I hear from people is kids need their dad…….this dad is terrible for his kids…..why do they need him?…and the girls are so young they dont even know him……so I guess my question is what should I do?? How do I deal with this guy?

    • Joel Wesley Hawbaker
      December 1, 2019

      Aaron, that’s definitely a hard spot to be in because in general the biological dads tend to have more rights than a stepdad. It’s very possible that the reason he’s now wanting more time with them is because you’re in the picture. I also understand your concern that perhaps the kids aren’t being properly cared for when they’re with him. Would it be possible for you to schedule time for him to see the girls while you’re there? Perhaps meet at a park or a local restaurant with a playground? That would give him a chance to see them and interact with them, and it would alleviate some of the time you feel they’re not being properly watched.

      It’s certainly a difficult spot, but in the long run it will be better if you can encourage the girls to have a relationship with their dad (provided everything is safe, etc). If you don’t, then as they get older, they may resent you and feel as though you’ve kept them from him, which would make things much more difficult overall.

  11. elishia
    December 7, 2019

    I’m a mother of 2 kids a 5 year old and soon to be 3 year old. Their dad wants to see them, i think every other week is fair but my spouse says that the kids dont need 2 dads and says only one weekend a month. He (my spouse) also says that since my 5 year old isnt his biological father ( only the 3 year old is) that he doesnt need to see him, but my ex has known him since he was a baby. I feel like its unfair and i just want everyone to be happy and it puts me at feeling immoral. We broke up because i was the only one working for over a year and a half and tho we werent in love he loved the boys. I think my spouse looks at this as interference in the relationship with my boys and our relationship as it progresses in the future. I’m so stressed out in just feeling like a decent human being in this situation plus im pregnant and it makes it feel even more difficult. It’s stretching me thin between love and morality. I always tell my boys if they ask that there biological dad loves them because i dont want them to ever think that someone stopped loving them even if they are just 5 and 3 and my spouse says that “kids are adaptable”. Anytime i mention having my kids see there dad a lil more as long as he does it and im not involved he tells me we should just move states, his way of avoiding it. in the past he has even threatened leaving me if it doesnt go his way, tho has says nothing will get in the way of us but he says im not loyal to him but my youngest sons dad.

    Please give me advice….
    maybe it is simple, maybe im a push over…
    but if the dad makes the effort to see both biological son and my other should he be able as long as he is doing his part……

    • JoelWHawbaker
      December 21, 2019

      I’m so sorry for the difficult position that you’re in. I want to encourage you about a few things, and I hope this proves helpful to you. First, I applaud your desire to try to do what is right by all the different parties involved; this is difficult, and I’m glad you’re trying! Second, I agree with you that, if the kids’ biological dad wants to see them more, and he is doing what he is supposed to for the kids, then he should be allowed to do that–for the most part. That is, you don’t want to purposely create more scheduling difficulties, but it’s also not a great idea for your current husband to say that the kids’ bio-dad isn’t allowed to see them more. Perhaps there is a way in which the bio-dad can see the kids that wouldn’t be too much of a scheduling problem for your husband: certain weeknights, or extra time on weekends, or something like that? Depending on where you live, perhaps the bio-dad could take them to school as they get older, etc? That’s why my father did for us after my parents’ divorce: we lived with Mom, but Dad took us to school every day, and so we got those few minutes with him consistently.

      I hope this gives you some encouragement, and also that it’s helpful to you!

  12. Ace
    January 7, 2020

    Hi. I am a stepdad and have been married to my wife for 3 years now. My wife was previously in an abusive marriage with the biological father. He has never acknowledged that he put his hands on her. When me and my wife started getting serious her ex pulled me to the side and basically told me that he didn’t acknowledge the role of a stepdad. I respectfully said to him that I just want to help her grow and that’s what was important to me, Fast forward to 3 years later, I have been really present in my daughters life (teaching her how to ride her bike, helping her with homework daily, and being at all of her functions). He still refuses to acknowledge my existence (in times when we have convos with our daughter regarding bad choices that are made in school he always says mommy and me think this). I believe that he is insecure and threatened in his position of dad. There have been several instances where the ex has lost his temper and called my wife all sorts of names (both while we were just dating and now that we are married). My wife does not want me to get physical with this guy as she feels it would lower us to his standards and it wouldn’t be a good visual for our daughter. So out of respect for them, I don’t react the way my heart is telling me too. I have hoped that this guy would grow up (find Jesus) and acknowledge what he did to her and change for his daughters sake but it has not happened and I am not sure it will at this point. this feels like a situation that could escalate at any moment because we are dealing with someone that I feel may have some type of disorder ( he will cuss someone out and then ac like nothing happened the next day). Anyone have any suggestions on how to deal with this. Thanks

    • JoelWHawbaker
      January 7, 2020

      Hi! First of all, let me say that I’m sorry to hear about the difficult situation that you are in. I can’t imagine how difficult that must be, especially as you want to protect your wife and your daughter. I applaud you for listening to your wife’s counsel, as I also feel that getting into any type of physical altercation with him (short of stopping him from harming your wife or daughter from an imminent danger) would not be good in the long run. He may or may not change, and he doesn’t seem to have tried to allow you any legitimacy in your role as stepfather. Again, I applaud you for your patience and willingness to do the work of a parent without getting the respect from him that you deserve! Though she may or may not realize it yet, your daughter will one day see what you are doing for her and how much you have helped her, despite that lack of respect from her father.

      If you truly believe that the ex-husband may have some type of disorder, I would encourage you to seek out a professional counselor for help (therapist, pastor, etc) in dealing with someone like that. I would hesitate to offer much advice without being closer to the situation, and so I’d recommend you talk to someone who may have more familiarity with the family and his story as well. What I can tell you is that what you are doing so far is correct: take care of your wife and daughter, be patient with him even when he’s disrespectful to you (in order to avoid escalating anything), and look for ways to continue helping your family. Thanks for setting an amazing example for your daughter!

    • CupHalf
      May 29, 2020

      As I read, I was amazed at how closely this mirrors my experience. The abuse in the past. The lack of acknowledgement that you exist, let alone are your daughter’s stepdad. The feeling that you have to sit on the sidelines while your wife gets shit on. Hoping the guy finds Jesus while grappling with your own primal desires to injure him (or worse). It’s a position that feels powerless and at times hopeless.

      Honestly, the good part of me is rooting for him to change by hearing you and for your relationship to improve. The bad part of me wants him to change because you cuss him out or knock his teeth in. The latter is bad and could make it much worse. For the former to happen, I think you know the only hope is to pray, take care of yourself, your wife, daughter, family, and be in the Spirit. If you can do that, then even if he stays the same, it won’t matter.

      Best of luck to you, I’m saying a prayer for you and your family. And thank you for sharing, it helps me, too.

  13. Inka
    February 8, 2020

    My hubby and I have been married for 3 years now. I have 2 sons from 2 different men. When my hubby came into our lives my boys were 3 and 6 well as of today they are 8 and 12 years old. We dated for 2 years and then got married. The last 2 years of our marriage have been very difficult for my sons and I. My hubby has started to pick on my youngest son, it seems to me. Possibly since we have to share custody with his bio-dad. We argue about his mistreatment of my 8 year old weekly. One moment my hubby will be kind and loving to my son and then the next min. he will be yelling at him and saying that I need to send him to live with his bio-dad due to the childs behavior. I am at a loss since I think that my hubby is overreacting about minor issues. I don’t know if I should look into divorce or family counseling, or does my hubby have mental issues I should consider.

    • JoelWHawbaker
      March 17, 2020

      Inka, that’s a tough spot to be in, and I’m sorry for where you are. I would certainly consider looking into family counseling, and I would encourage you to try to find a counselor who specializes in blended family situations because the dynamics are so different than they are in traditional nuclear families.

  14. CupHalf
    May 29, 2020


    I’ve been with my girlfriend for close to three years and are planning to get married soon. She has a six year old and the bio father is very difficult; he has a history of mental illness but is very high functioning and has a good support system around him. It is an extremely frustrating situation because as soon as she found out we were dating, he began to regress in his behavior towards her. He’s narcissistic and manic depressive; I thought we’d gotten off on the best foot possible when we met, but that was quickly dispelled when I found out from her that he was making paranoid, accusatory statements about me. Suddenly, her parenting, which had been good for 3+years, was lacking in his mind, and I was the cause.

    She revealed to me that he’d always had a deluded idea that they’d get back together, and at one point he drove to her parents house and confessed to her parents that he was a changed man for the better and that she just needed to see it. Meanwhile, when he was picking up or dropping his daughter off, he would make a point to linger and start “discussions” with the mother about unfair issues in their custodial agreement in front of me and the children. Whenever he saw me or was forced to interact with me, he was guaranteed to send long, complaining texts or emails to her about past grievances. When I wasn’t around, tensions lifted and the reams of texts stopped. My girlfriend and I agreed it was best to minimize interactions between him and me.

    I noticed a pattern of her freezing up in his presence, and felt confused when she told me that she had not wanted him in her home for some time before she’d even met me. I still have the sense that her communication with others, including me, has been damaged by her past relationship – she often buries things and forges ahead, accomplishing a lot but feeling miserable and not present in the day to day joys.

    One time, when I wasn’t there (I was visiting her about once a week at the time), he “bucked” at her during one of their arguments, and she put out a restrictive order on him. It was not the first such order; he had been violent with her before, had been arrested, and committed. The guilt she felt now was due to her faith in him at the time, which led her to not press charges and to keep giving him more chances. The next time he came for pickup he had to stay outside, so he proclaims to his child, “Sorry, we can’t go in the house anymore because of Mom’s boyfriend.” I heard this, and contrary to our agreement, went outside to tell him that I had nothing to do with him not being welcome in her home anymore. He responded that “there was a lot I didn’t know about,” and, almost cryptically, “It’ll all come out in court.”

    Since then, my girlfriend and I broke up for six months (their coparenting relationship improved, surprise), we got back together (it worsened), and I moved in and we got engaged. I asked when she thought she was going to tell him, knowing full well something would go wrong. When she did, his response was to file a CPS report alleging I was abusing their daughter.

    The case was closed after we were interviewed by CPS and police. The officer sighed a little and then said, “This is a guy who is going to twist everything, and it probably isn’t going to be the last time something like this happens.” The CPS investigator said it would be best to minimize all interactions with the father.

    We never raised the issue with him, something that at the time seemed strategic (and was reiterated by her lawyer), but it’s left the equivalent of an 8,000 pound elephant breathing fire and spitting napalm in the room whenever we interact. A couple weeks later, he had to pick something up and my fiance wasn’t home. Every fiber in my being was on fire waiting, alternating thoughts of fight and flight swirling through my head. I remembered how I’d reached out to him upon our first meeting years ago (literally – He had sat stone faced and she frozen while I, a complete novice at parents and single parents and kids, was made mediator and peacemaker by default.). Back then, I’d humanized him to her, defended him as better than the worst of his actions, talked about my own struggles with depression. Now, I had to greet the person who accused me of molesting a child, whom I knew would never acknowledge that he’d done it let alone feel remorse for it.

    I gave him what he came for, and asked him if he could talk with me. He said he didn’t have time, he had to go. As he stepped away I told him that I thought “it would be a good thing if we did.” He seemed to consider it before brushing it away. “Maybe someday.”

    It’s been months, and now, in the pandemic, there are more handoffs than ever. His violations of the custody agreement seemed bad, but, in light of the courts being closed and him being on good behavior, we’ve been counseled that we might need to wait for him to “lose control” before modifying custody.

    At the end of the day, I think he’s a good father in a lot of ways. Just a bad coparent. I wished our relationship could be better, but it feels too late. I feel like I’ve become stuffed into the same position my fiance has felt herself in – forced to fake nice, keep things under wraps, hope things get better, all while there’s always an expectation he’s going to ruin her day at best, and at worst, do something crazy. He’s good to his kids, acts one way to our faces, and then gets behind his keyboard or phone.

    I really appreciate the site and this thread. I have never been on a forum until now, and found the stories from bio dads and stepdads helpful, as well as your feedback and suggestions. I apologize for the length of my post…it’s been good to vent, though. Your advice to invite the biological father for coffee or a beer, unless he’s totally irrational, made me pause. This guy’s ability to rationalize is on a special level, but that’s also because he’s able to rationalize away every single bad thing he’s done.

    I was wholly unprepared for dating a single parent, let alone one with ex troubles. I’ve learned on the fly and grown close to the children, but it feels more and more like a trap and I’m unsure about going forward with the marriage.

  15. NEE JAY
    November 24, 2020

    Me and my Boyfriend have been together for 11 years, my oldest son 12 years old has a different dad, his biological dad has never truly been in his life when he was a toddler he would come visit him and promise to pick him up and blow it off with some excuse. Recently he messaged me on social media to ask about his son my son asked if he can have communication with him, I did communicate to my boyfriend that he would like to be able to talk to his biological dad he wasn’t very happy about it and said I shouldn’t have told him, now my son and his biological dad want to meet up for lunch and my boyfriend doesn’t agree with it he says whats the point of him being in his life for 11 years, just for a guy who hasn’t been in his life to come and get what he wants when he wants. I’m so unsure what to do because I don’t want anyone to be upset any advice would be really appreciated.

    • admin
      December 18, 2020

      That’s a very tough situation, and I can understand each side of it. Your boyfriend has a point, but I also believe that if a person’s biological parent wants to try to reconnect with their child, they should be given the opportunity to do so. If your son’s dad wants to try to build a relationship with him, and if your son wants to do so, then I would encourage you to try to help that happen (unless, of course, there are dangerous red-flag issues: drugs, abuse, etc.) in a safe way. Good luck!

  16. Gabi Poloni
    January 11, 2021

    Mom of one

    I’m a young mom to a child less than a year old and my ex who I’m trying my best to co-parent with is a very flaky person yet a major control freak with everything that has to do with my son including the name we gave him. (example I said James he wanted John 🙁
    He doesn’t care for anyone but himself and makes a lot of promises I know he will never keep. finally, he also doesn’t respect boundaries and wants to show up at my parent’s apartment where I still live.
    Eventually, I do plan on marrying someone else in the future and would really hope I don’t run into problems like this.
    Let me know what advice you can give me

    • admin
      January 18, 2021

      Mom of One,

      that’s a tough spot, and I can tell you that it is possible for the situation to get better as time goes on. Remember that early on, everyone’s emotions are still going to be very raw, and thus everything feels even bigger than it may actually be. However, I’d recommend that you check out some resources by Ron Deal (Family Life Blended) including his podcast and some of his books. They provide great wisdom about how to move forward regarding co-parenting, dating as a single parent, etc. I wish you the best of luck!


Leave a Reply

CLICK HERE to get your Complete Stepfamily Tool Kit FREE!
The COMPLETE Stepfamily Toolkit e-book includes: 5 Topics for Every Blended Family to Discuss, The 7-Day Blended Family Devotional (based on Proverbs), AND The 10 Commandments for Blended Family Life PLUS three bonus resources!
We respect your privacy and won't share your email with ANY third party groups!